McCormick’s telling, covering the better part of a century, boasts both sweep and depth. Early Frankford Swedenborgians like Maskell Carll, the first minister of The First New Jerusalem Church in the City of Philadelphia, and “humble instruments” like Thomas Seddon found success preaching “Swedenborg’s doctrines to working-class people,” forging “an independent religious path, born of diversity and imbued with an ecumenical vision” and emphasizing a spiritual sense of scripture as well as “local activism to generate ‘happiness’ and community betterment.” McCormick notes that the faith was often misunderstood, and accounts of theological controversies, schisms, and occasional outside pushback will fascinate scholars of American faith.
The story of the Swedenborgians reflects the story of the nation itself, as McCormick’s rich chapters, each covering a half decade or so, explore local impacts of national news and politics, as well as local and community issues. The narrative draws deeply on local publications, digging into customs, the practicalities of community-building, news events like fires and new businesses, and reports on controversies and the Society’s responses, like Rev. B. F. Barrett’s 1866 sermon in support of desegregating Philadelphia streetcars. The level of detail is likely too granular for readers of pop histories, but McCormick offers a feast of insights, connections, and revelations.
Takeaway: Richly detailed history of Swedenborgian Christians near 18th century Philadelphia.
Comparable Titles: Marguerite Block’s The New Church in the New World, Harry C. Silcox and Frank W. Hollingsworth’s Northeast Philadelphia.
Production grades
Cover: B
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A