Dayton, a journalist and small-town resident herself, has a perfect eye and ear for what makes towns like North Meadows unique. She does a fine job outlining the different factions in town, sometimes competing, sometimes aligning, as with conservation: for example, one group backs the idea of cutting trees near power lines for safety, while another wants to see trees preserved. The subtle but important class distinctions among the residents come across, as when we learn the descendants of the original settlers have special "members only" meetings. Occasionally, town life crowds out the central mystery, but there's no doubt we get a deep view of North Meadows.
Dayton singles out a few members of the large cast for in-depth development. We get local politician Shelby, who views his elected service to the town "as an indication of social stature, rather than as public service." His journey through the book hovers between pathos and comedy. And investigator Abbott is an interesting cipher, with such close ties to the community we're left wondering if he's too close to uncover the killers. In the end, though, Dayton gives us a resolution for the mystery— and the town, and if it's not what every character wants, it's at least something they can all accept.
Takeaway: Mysterious and deadly stone towers in a vividly realized small town.
Comparable Titles: Tom Bouman’s Fateful Mornings, Louise Penny.
Production grades
Cover: A-
Design and typography: A-
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: B
Marketing copy: B