Assessment:

Plot/Idea: This engrossing story takes place during a pivotal time in world history, and Suchman adds careful detail to the set up, particularly in the novel's beginning. That slows the pace initially, but Alice's story is also lovingly constructed in the process.

Prose: Suchman is a reliable writer, able to establish a sound framework for this historically significant novel. The prose is direct and steady, capably narrating the book's tense, tragic experiences.

Originality: This work is a fictionalized account of a true story, enhanced for context and storytelling. Suchman breathes vivid life into Alice's story, making her a memorable—and inspiring—character. 

Character/Execution: Suchman is skilled with characterization, particularly with Alice, but also with Selma, Emma, and Alfred. Readers will be deeply impacted by their tragic stories, long after their fate is revealed.

Date Submitted: July 16, 2024