As with earlier entries, a zest for adventure powers The Bear’s Claw, plus a keen interest in the brothers’ development, as men, leaders, and as practitioners of the assorted skills. Fans of the series will enjoy seeing how they’ve grown, while new readers are advised to start with the first book, though Jensen fills in the basics on the fly here.The story is nicely paced, written with striking detail and an attention to what all this mayhem actually feels like, an approach that engages readers and encourages caring about these characters and their world. This entry feels a touch more violent than the previous, the high stakes reflecting the brothers’ maturation, and Jensen does not fear to force characters to face loss.
Despite the emphasis on brothers, the series boasts a diverse cast, including female characters of all ages represented as fierce, capable, brave members of the population, and none of the dated tropes involving gender that readers might associate with heroic adventure fantasies involving royalty. The story allows any reader to imagine themselves as the hero–and what heroism might cost.
Takeaway: Rousing climax to a strong middle grade fantasy series in the classic vein.
Comparable Titles: Cindy Lin’s The Twelve, Torsten Weitze’s The 13th Paladin series, Brandon Mull’s Fablehaven series.
Production grades
Cover: A
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A