Each volume in the series offers readers a panoramic glimpse of one of the sisters, and this time Helen’s firmly on center stage. Her troubled past, including a sexual assault in high school and her own sketchy choices at her law firm, comes rushing back during the group’s multi-day hike, and Ballard structures the bond between the sisters—regardless of their petty disagreements—as the glue that will help Helen get her life back on track. Their camaraderie is heartwarming, and their attempts to restore closeness and help each other through troubles keeps the tone upbeat.
Ballard reveals Helen’s past secrets—and her perceived failure as a mother to her son Jacob—subtly, mirroring the shame and fear Helen feels at the thought of opening up to her family. Though that diminishes the emotional payoff when she finally bares her soul, it fits her personality and role within the family—Helen, “the big sister they needed,” believes she’s there to help her sisters “live better lives.” Ultimately, she realizes expecting herself to be perfect only hurts the people she loves, recognizing she is, in the end, “enough”—just the way she is.
Takeaway: Estranged sisters bond during a grueling family trek.
Comparable Titles: Barbara O’Neal’s The Starfish Sisters, Blair Thornburgh’s Ordinary Girls.
Production grades
Cover: A
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: A
Marketing copy: A