As they battle for their very existence, these brave teens fight the eternal quest of good versus evil, complete with beasts, replicants, and a lost city—and lovers of YA SF adventures will be enchanted by the ride. Told alternately by Grace and Duncan and selected supporting cast, the story takes its characters on an epic journey, rife with unexpected twists and turns that will keep readers quickly turning the pages. Grace is an especially engaging character, and her journey will resonate most. Minor editing issues at times distract, but Ash’s talent for plotting, her richly painted universe, and her well-drawn characters and dialogue compel.
The tale is imaginative and suspenseful, especially for a second book, as the heroes dare to head into the last place anyone expects, the war-ravaged, now-overgrown Wilds. Ash wrings memorable tension from their desperation, from the possibility of lost lore and magic, and most of all the pursuit of Stone Tiran’s soldiers. It all builds to a cliffhanger as the survivors battle to stay alive and debate where to travel to next. Readers who have joined their dangerous journey will likely be eager for the next installment of this engaging story.
Takeaway: This epic adventure will enchant readers who enjoy SF worlds and flawed characters.
Great for fans of: Amie Kaufman and Meagan Spooner’s Starbound series, Beth Revis’s Across the Universe.
Production grades
Cover: B+
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: N/A
Editing: B+
Marketing copy: A-