Younger readers will instantly fall for Merz’s soul-eyed, happy-dancing pup, who, despite the hard knocks of her life on the street, manages to keep an innocent trust in the world around her. Every time she runs into people, she tries her best to impress, in hopes of finding a friend; more often than not, that ends with her mistreatment, as when a group of school children laugh at her and throw rocks, prompting her to cry “why don’t those kids like me?” Readers will be crushed at the puppy’s despair, and empathize with her melancholy: “I’m cute, I dance, and I give smiley smiles. What’s not to like” she whimpers.
Thankfully, this teary tale has a warm, fuzzy ending, as the puppy meets a teacher named Jean, who steps in at just the right moment to save her from calamity, gifting her with a collar and a name of her own—Parker. Hefke’s bold illustrations bring Parker to vivid life, from her expressive puppy eyes to her excited jumping, and her declaration at the end—that a collar “feels so good… Like love” will thaw even the hardest hearts.
Takeaway: Sweet tale of a pup finding their forever home.
Comparable Titles: Lisa Papp’s Madeline Finn and the Shelter Dog, Kelly Collier’s The Imposter.
Production grades
Cover: B
Design and typography: A
Illustrations: B+
Editing: A-
Marketing copy: A